Books, Opinions, and Beyond: A Talk with Sameer Gudhate on the Art of Review

Sameer Gudhate is a multifaceted individual from Mumbai, India, known for his contributions in literature, sports, and digital content creation.

He is also an author, ghostwriter, poet, proofreader, and beta reader, actively sharing his writings on platforms like Medium.

An Exclusive conversation with Sameer Gudhate.

1. What first sparked your passion for book reviewing, and how has the journey shaped you?

I’ve been a bookworm for as long as I can remember, losing myself in stories and letting them shape my imagination. Growing up, books were my constant companions, sparking ideas and dreams. At one point, I had this big idea of selling books online—it felt like the perfect Was Dancing in the Face of Trolling: Aditya’s Inspiring Story to turn my love for reading into something tangible. But life had other plans, and that dream didn’t quite take off.

Then came the pandemic, a time that shifted so much for all of us. Like many, I found myself searching for connection and purpose in a world that felt suddenly disconnected. That’s when I decided to start posting book reviews on social media. What began as a simple way to share my thoughts quickly turned into something far deeper.

Reviewing books has been nothing short of transformative. It’s taught me empathy by stepping into the lives of characters, critical thinking by dissecting plots and themes, and even the art of storytelling itself. But more than that, it’s shaped how I view the world—helping me embrace different perspectives, understand emotions better, and find beauty in the smallest details.

Along the way, I’ve met amazing authors and connected with a vibrant community of readers. These connections have fueled my passion and inspired me to set ambitious goals—like reviewing 365 books in 365 days, a journey that challenged and changed me in ways I never imagined. What started as a small passion project has become a deeply fulfilling part of who I am, and I wouldn’t trade it for anything.

2. Can you share a childhood book that deeply influenced your love for reading?

It’s tough to pick just one book, as so many stories shaped my love for reading. I spent a lot of time in my local library, and honestly, it became my second home. I can still feel the excitement of walking through those doors, the shelves stretching out in front of me, each one offering a new adventure. During school vacations, I’d go there at least twice a day, eager to get lost in the world of books.

The librarian was a big part of why I kept coming back. She had this way of encouraging me to explore new stories, always suggesting books that matched my tastes but also pushed me to try something different. Her kindness made all the difference, and I honestly think I owe my love for reading to her gentle guidance.

I spent countless hours devouring books like Hardy Boys, Nancy Drew, and anything by Enid Blyton. Those books took me to places filled with mystery and excitement, and I couldn’t wait to turn the next page.

All these little moments, the joy of discovering a new story and the warmth from a librarian who always had a recommendation ready, created a love for reading that has lasted my whole life. It wasn’t just about escaping into stories—it was about how those stories helped me shape my own view of the world, one page at a time.

3. How do you decide which books make it to your review list out of so many options?

As a professional book reviewer, my personal tastes no longer take the front seat when it comes to picking books for review. I’ve learned to approach it with a sense of responsibility, knowing that my reviews will help guide my readers’ choices. So, I try to choose books that have something meaningful to offer—not just to me, but to my audience too.

I do receive books from authors and publishing houses, and these play a big part in my review list. When a publisher or author reaches out, I usually start by reading the pitch or summary to see if the book has something unique or timely to offer. If I feel that it fits into a larger conversation or brings something fresh to the table, it often jumps to the top of my list.

Alongside those, I keep an eye on the buzz. Whether it’s fellow reviewers, online communities, or social media chatter, if a book’s making waves, I’m eager to dive in and form my own perspective. I also look for books that push me out of my comfort zone—books that challenge me, whether in their writing style, themes, or genre. I think it’s important to step outside of what feels familiar, to keep my reviewing experience exciting and dynamic.

At the end of the day, I focus on books that will bring something valuable to my readers—whether that’s a new point of view, a voice that hasn’t been heard enough, or a story that’s beautifully told. I aim to pick books that will leave an impression, not just on me, but on those who trust my opinion.

4. Physical books, eBooks, or audiobooks—what’s your go-to format and why?

When it comes to formats, I’m a die-hard fan of physical books. There’s something special about holding a book in your hands, the way the pages feel as you turn them, the smell of the paper—everything about it just makes the experience so real and immersive. It’s not just about reading the words, but about being fully connected to the story in a way that feels almost tangible.

But, let’s be real—eBooks come in handy, especially when I’m on the go. When I’m traveling or short on space, having an entire library in my pocket is a lifesaver. I can adjust the text to my liking, which is a small touch that makes a big difference. Plus, it’s so easy to buy a new book or pick up where I left off without carrying any extra weight.

As for audiobooks, I haven’t quite jumped on that bandwagon yet. I haven’t listened to a single one, and honestly, I’m not sure if I ever will. For me, reading has always been about the physical connection with the book—the act of flipping through pages, seeing my progress, and just being in the moment with the words. It’s not something I’m ready to swap for listening just yet. Maybe one day, but for now, I’m perfectly content with the comfort of my physical books and the convenience of eBooks.

5. Are there genres you’re drawn to more than others? What about them captivates you?

When it comes to books, I have a soft spot for a few genres that always seem to pull me in. Murder mysteries, for example, are a genre I can never get enough of. The thrill of trying to solve the case, to figure out what’s really going on before the protagonist does—it’s addictive. But if I’m being totally honest, espionage is probably my ultimate favorite. James Bond, in particular, is something I come back to again and again. I’ve read his books multiple times, and each time, I get swept up in the high-stakes world of secret missions, hidden agendas, and the smooth, dangerous charm of 007. There’s something timeless about it, isn’t there? Every twist feels like it could happen in the real world, making it all the more exciting.

Self-help books also have a special place in my life. They’ve taught me a lot about growth, managing my thoughts, and how to tackle the challenges life throws my way. It’s not just about the advice; it’s the way these books make me pause, reflect, and think differently.

And then there’s poetry. Poetry’s always been a bit like a secret language for me. The beauty of it—the way a few words can make you feel like you’re seeing the world in a completely new way. It’s more than just writing; it’s an experience. There’s a rawness and depth to it that stays with me long after I’ve read it.

Each of these genres feels like a different world I can lose myself in. Whether it’s the mystery, the thrill, the personal growth, or the deep emotions—each one has a way of grabbing me and making me think, feel, and, most importantly, connect.

6. What motivated you to review 365 books in 365 days, setting a world record? What kept you going?

This whole journey didn’t start as a grand challenge. It was much more spontaneous than that. Authors and publishers were sending me books, and I found myself reading and reviewing them one after another. It became a natural part of my daily routine, like breathing. Then, one day, I happened to scroll through my Facebook page and realized I had been reviewing books non-stop for an entire year—366 days, to be precise! That’s when the thought crossed my mind, Hey, could this be a world record?

I started looking into it, and to my surprise, I found there was no existing record for reviewing this many books in a row. That’s when I decided to take the leap and apply for it. The process was a bit of a blur, gathering all the necessary documents and submitting them, but before I knew it, the record was officially recognized.

What really kept me going throughout the year wasn’t just the goal of setting a record; it was the simple joy of reading and the sense of connection it gave me with so many authors, stories, and fellow readers. Every day was a new chapter, a new adventure. It became part of my daily rhythm, and the thought of helping others discover books and authors they might not have come across otherwise kept me motivated. It wasn’t about the number—it was about the love for reading, the excitement of discovery, and the satisfaction of sharing that passion with others.

7. For someone aspiring to review books, where should they start?

If you're thinking about diving into book reviewing, my advice is to start small and let your passion guide you. There’s no need to have it all figured out right away—just begin by reading. Read as much as you can, but don't feel pressured to stick to a single genre. The world of books is vast, and the more you explore, the more you’ll discover what excites you.

Once you’ve read something that sparks a reaction, start writing about it. Don’t worry about making it perfect; just share your thoughts, even if it’s just a few sentences. You can start posting on your own blog, Goodreads, or any platform where fellow readers hang out. Share what moved you about the book—whether it was the characters, the storyline, or how it made you feel. Don’t be afraid to express your honest opinions, but always be respectful, especially when you’re critiquing.

Building a network within the bookish community is essential, too. It’s not just about reading and reviewing, but also about connecting with other readers, authors, and publishers. Engage in conversations, ask for recommendations, and be open to discovering new voices. This helps you grow and also keeps your reading experience fresh.

Most importantly, don’t rush. It takes time to find your own style, and that’s okay. Reviewing books is a journey, and as you write more, you’ll develop your unique approach. The best part is that if you’re genuinely enjoying the process, it’ll show in your reviews, and that’s when you really start to connect with people. So, start where you are, keep reading, keep sharing, and the rest will follow naturally.

8. How do you approach reviewing a book? Is there a specific method or flow you follow?

I do have a method that I follow, though it’s one that’s evolved over time as I’ve gotten more into book reviewing. For me, the first and most important step is reading the book from cover to cover, no shortcuts. I believe every page has something to offer, so I immerse myself in the whole experience. As I read, I jot down quick notes—thoughts that pop up, things that strike me, characters I connect with, or moments that make me pause. These little notes serve as my anchors when I’m ready to write the review.

Once I finish the book, I don’t rush to write. I give myself some space—about two days. This break allows me to process everything I’ve read, giving my mind a chance to step back and reflect on the bigger picture. It’s crucial to take a moment before diving into the review so I can approach it with a fresh perspective.

When I finally sit down to craft my review, I start with the basics—introducing the book and touching on the general premise. But I don’t stop there. I dig deeper into the heart of the story: the themes, the characters, the emotions it evoked. I also reflect on the writing style, how the author’s choices affected the flow and pacing of the story. It’s important to me that my review doesn’t just summarize what happened—it’s more about sharing how the book made me feel, what I took away from it.

Once I’ve written the first draft, I step away again. I take another two-day break. When I come back to it, I approach it with fresh eyes. I tweak, refine, and fine-tune the review so it feels just right—clear, engaging, and honest. After that, it’s good to go.

This process, while detailed, helps me stay grounded and consistent in my reviews. It allows me to capture the true essence of each book, giving readers a genuine feel for what they can expect when they pick it up.

9. What impact do you think your reviews have on readers and authors alike?

When I write a review, I don't just aim to share my thoughts—I want it to spark something meaningful in both readers and authors. For readers, I hope my reviews offer more than just a quick judgment of whether a book is "good" or "bad." I want to give them a real sense of what the book is about, what it feels like, and why it might be worth their time. Everyone’s looking for a book that speaks to them, and if I can help someone find that connection, then I’ve done my part.

For authors, I see my reviews as a way of starting a conversation. I know how much heart goes into writing a book, so I try to approach every review with respect. My goal isn’t just to highlight what I loved, but to share insights that might help the author see their work from a new angle. It’s not about tearing things down, but about offering thoughtful feedback that can help them grow. I’ve had authors reach out to me, expressing how certain pieces of feedback helped them evolve, and that always means a lot to me.

At the end of the day, my reviews are about connection. I want to help readers make informed choices and also encourage authors to keep pushing boundaries, knowing that someone is paying attention to their work and genuinely considering how it fits into the bigger literary conversation. That, to me, is the most fulfilling part of the entire process.

10. Are there books you’ve reviewed that stand out as all-time favorites? What makes them special?

Some books have a way of lingering in your mind long after you’ve finished reading them, and these are the ones that I can’t help but think back to every now and then.

How to Get From Where You Are to Where You Want to Be by Jack Canfield is one of those books. It's not just about goal-setting—it feels like a personal guidebook to crafting a life you truly want. The way Canfield lays out his steps with so much clarity made me realize how simple yet powerful the concept of setting clear intentions is. I’ve come back to it many times when I’ve needed direction.

Then, Bombay Review and Other Short Stories by Ravi Valluri grabbed me with its raw, vivid portrayal of life in Mumbai. The stories take you on a ride through the hustle and chaos of the city, making you feel like you’re living right there, in the middle of it all. There’s a depth to the characters and situations that you don’t often come across, making it an unforgettable read.

Nalisa’s Universe: A Collection of Poems by Nalisa Chopra is another one that I can’t shake off. The way she captures emotions in a few lines is almost magical. The poetry is introspective, often leaving you thinking about the broader truths of life, love, and everything in between. It’s one of those books you read slowly, letting each poem settle before moving to the next.

Beyond Borders by Mosam Shah really struck a chord with me. It’s about so much more than just crossing physical borders—it dives deep into the emotional and cultural ones we all face. The themes of identity and belonging resonated with me on a personal level, and it felt like a story that everyone could connect to, no matter where they’re from.

Lastly, I have to mention The Protectors of Kavaach and The Protected Rakshasa KAAL by Pranay Bhalerao. These books took me to a world of ancient myths, magical creatures, and epic adventures. There’s something so captivating about how they blend fantasy with real human emotion. The Kavaach Trilogy kept me on the edge of my seat, and even now, I find myself thinking about the world Pranay created.

These books are more than just stories—they’ve made me reflect, feel, and even grow in some ways. Each one has a special place in my heart for how they moved me, challenged my thinking, and connected with me on a deeper level.

 

Got it! Here’s a humanized version based on your personal reviews:

11. Have you ever come across an underrated book that deserves more love? What made it unique?

Absolutely, there are several books that I've come across which, in my opinion, deserve far more recognition than they currently get. One such book is The Founding Fathers of Fraud: Independent India’s First Scandals that Rocked the Nation by Bhaswar Mukherjee. It dives deep into the Dalmia and Mundhra scams—two of the biggest financial scandals in the country’s early years. What makes it stand out is how the author not only brings the historical details to light but also makes it an engaging read. The depth of research and the way he presents the story in a way that feels fresh and gripping makes this book incredibly valuable. It’s a fantastic read for anyone interested in true crime or India’s political history.

Then there's A.M. Naik: The Man Who Built Tomorrow by Priya Kumar and Jairam N. Menon. Released in May 2024, this one truly piqued my interest. It’s a fascinating look at A.M. Naik, the man behind L&T’s transformation into a global leader. What I really appreciated about this book was how it captured the essence of Naik’s leadership, vision, and the struggles he faced in building one of India’s most iconic companies. The depth of insight into business and leadership is refreshing, making it more than just a biography.

Another remarkable book is Plentiful Springs by Anjaly Thomas, which I reviewed earlier this year. This one is a beautiful exploration of self-discovery and inner peace. Anjaly has a unique ability to draw you into her words in a way that feels like an intimate conversation. The book offers deep reflections on life, and it’s one of those reads that lingers long after you’ve turned the last page. It’s a great example of how poetry and prose can intertwine to offer solace and wisdom.

All of these books may not have received the mainstream love they deserve, but in my view, they offer something truly unique. Each of them brings a new perspective—whether it’s on India’s early financial history, leadership, or the journey of self-reflection. They’ve left an impact on me, and I think they deserve far more attention.

12. How has your reviewing style evolved since your first review?

When I look back at the very first review I posted in February 2021, it feels like stepping into a time machine. I was still so new to the whole process—figuring out what works and what doesn’t, finding my own rhythm. My first review was simple and straight to the point, almost a bullet-point list of what I liked and didn’t like about the book. I didn’t really know how to weave my emotions into the review or why certain things in the book resonated with me. It was more about the basics—“here’s the plot, here’s my opinion.”

But over time, I began to understand that a book review isn’t just about recounting the plot or listing likes and dislikes. It’s about sharing an experience—how a book made me feel, what it taught me, and how it stuck with me long after I put it down. That’s when I started diving deeper, thinking more about the underlying messages in the book, the characters, and the themes. I started asking myself questions like: “What did this book make me think about life?” or “How does the story relate to the world around us?”

I also realized that the reviews didn’t have to be all business. I began to bring a little more of myself into them, sharing how a particular part of the book made me feel, or how it reminded me of something from my own life. It wasn’t just about reviewing the book—it was about connecting with readers on a personal level, making them feel like they were having a conversation with me, not just reading a review.

As my style evolved, I started to bring in more structure to my reviews. I’d outline key points—what worked, what didn’t—and then tie it all together with my final thoughts. But I made sure to keep it conversational. No jargon, no overly complex terms—just my thoughts, raw and real.

And perhaps the biggest shift was realizing that a review isn’t just about telling others whether or not a book is good. It’s about giving readers a window into my own experience. How did this book make me think? What emotions did it stir up? What lessons did I take away? These became the heart of my reviews.

Looking back at where I started, I’m proud of how far I’ve come. What began as a simple activity has turned into something much more meaningful. It’s become a way for me to connect with authors, fellow readers, and even myself. And every review I write now is an opportunity to learn and grow, not just as a reviewer, but as someone who loves the magic of books.

There are so many individuals who have had a profound influence on my journey as a book reviewer, each leaving their mark in a way that resonates deeply with me.

When it comes to authors, I’m continually inspired by those who have the ability to make you feel something with just a few words. Authors like Ruskin Bond and R.K. Narayan have this magical ability to capture the simplicity of life’s little moments. The way they weave emotion into their stories, often with minimalism, is what truly moves me. Their writing invites you into a world where even the smallest of details feel significant, and that's something I try to bring to my reviews—capturing that kind of emotional depth, even if it’s just a small piece of it.

Then there are the reviewers who really stand out to me. They’ve honed their craft in a way that goes beyond simply talking about the plot or characters—they dive into the essence of a book, its themes, the feelings it evokes, and the lasting impact it leaves behind. Many of them create video reviews, and I’ve often found myself captivated by the way they connect with their audiences. They bring such energy and life to their reviews, making books seem even more vivid and compelling. That’s something I aspire to do, bringing my own unique energy and passion into the world of book reviewing.

Alongside video reviews, I’ve also come across some wonderful book podcasts that keep me inspired. Shows like What Should I Read Next?, The Book Review, and Overdue have become part of my regular listening routine. The way these hosts casually discuss books, diving into deep yet accessible conversations, is something I admire. Their genuine love for literature is contagious, and it makes me want to explore this format as well. I hope to someday add my voice to the conversation and contribute to that vibrant world of book discussions.

Right now, there’s so much happening in the world of books and publishing that’s really lighting up my excitement.

One trend that’s really close to my heart is the growing spotlight on diverse voices and stories that move beyond the traditional ones we’ve been so used to. There’s a beautiful shift happening where books are embracing more representation—stories that come from different cultures, backgrounds, and experiences. It’s thrilling to see readers finally getting access to books that offer fresh perspectives, helping us all challenge old norms and see the world in ways we might never have thought about before. It’s a movement that feels like it’s opening doors for both authors and readers, and I’m all for it.

Another trend that’s been catching my attention is the rise of hybrid genres. More and more, authors are blending different genres, creating books that can’t just be neatly placed in one category. I’ve come across books that mix historical fiction with fantasy or sci-fi with romance, and honestly, it’s so refreshing. These kinds of stories feel limitless, and they really stretch the boundaries of creativity. It’s like diving into a world where the rules of genre don’t apply, and you’re free to explore whatever new narrative an author wants to bring to life. And that’s such a cool space to be in.

I also can’t ignore the growing wave of book podcasts and online communities. It’s amazing how these platforms are making books even more interactive. Podcasts like What Should I Read Next? and The Book Review are creating spaces where listeners can engage, share, and dive deeper into books they love. It’s an incredible way to connect with others who share the same passion for reading, and it’s so inspiring to be part of such a vibrant community.

When I think about where books and publishing are headed, the possibilities feel endless. There’s so much creativity and innovation happening right now, and I can’t wait to see how it all unfolds in the future!

Balancing my own preferences with what my readers expect has been a learning experience, and I think it’s something that evolves with time. At the heart of it, I try to remain true to myself—my feelings toward a book, my emotional connection to its story, and my honest opinions. I’ve always believed that authenticity is key, so I make sure to express what I really think. But I also know that my readers come from different walks of life, with varying interests and expectations.

For me, it’s all about striking a balance. When I’m reviewing, I focus on sharing my personal take on a book, but I also try to think about what might be helpful to someone who has different preferences. Let’s say I’m reviewing a fantasy novel. I might not usually gravitate toward that genre, but I can still evaluate the world-building, the character development, and the overall pacing in a way that others who enjoy fantasy would appreciate.

I also make it a point to recognize when a book might appeal to different audiences. If it’s something I didn’t particularly enjoy, I’ll still highlight its strengths so others can make their own decisions. My goal is to make my reviews relatable and helpful, providing insights that will resonate with both people who share my taste and those with different ones.

It’s been really important for me to listen to my readers, too. Their feedback has been invaluable in understanding what they appreciate most in a review. Over time, I’ve learned how to strike that balance, making sure I stay true to my voice while offering something that feels relevant and useful to others. It’s all about finding that sweet spot where my personal reflections and the expectations of my readers align.

If you're aiming to make a mark in book reviewing, my best advice would be to start from a place of passion and authenticity. Don’t try to mimic what others are doing—be true to your own voice. When you’re genuinely excited about a book, that energy comes through in your review. It's about connecting with your readers on a personal level, almost like you're recommending a book to a close friend. If you’re passionate about what you're reading, your words will naturally resonate with others.

Consistency is another piece of the puzzle. It doesn't matter if you’re posting every week or once a month—what matters is that you’re showing up. When readers know they can rely on you for thoughtful reviews, they’ll start coming back for more. Trust is the cornerstone of any reviewer-reader relationship, and building that trust takes time.

Also, don’t be afraid to stretch your limits. You’ll grow as a reviewer if you're open to reading books outside of your usual genres or comfort zones. Challenge yourself to look at books from new perspectives, understand different writing styles, and even explore literary techniques. It’s all part of developing your voice and craft.

And let’s not forget about building a community. Interacting with other readers and reviewers, whether through social media or local book clubs, is an invaluable way to learn, share, and exchange ideas. Book reviewing doesn’t have to be a solitary endeavor—it’s part of a larger conversation within a passionate, like-minded community.

Above all, remember that there’s no one-size-fits-all formula for reviewing. The key is to stay true to yourself, keep engaging, and keep learning. Your unique perspective is what will set your reviews apart, so embrace it fully.